This was in the quick arena of all places, too. We both had flags in the corners behind two bombs. I had a general left and he had a general and a scout. I offered a tie during my turn with the assumption that he, having played 1600+ games, would understand that I would never let his general attack mine.
He refused the tie, claiming that he deserved the win because of his extra player. Over the next hour (check the clock to verify), he tried to confuse me as to which player was the general, which didn't work, as the pictures will reveal. Even after the scout was removed, he still refused my tie requests. The only reason I won was because this clown's time buffer ran out.
Regardless of whether his actions qualify as "cheating" or not, this website needs to show they are committed to the quality of the gameplay here by banning players like this. If this site fails, it will only be because of their refusal to regulate the quality of the gameplay.